Your Cart

Your bag is currently empty.

Continue browsing here.

Skip to content

Two Favorite Brands - Tender Leaf Toys & Picasso Tiles - 30% Off (discount applied at checkout)

Bicycle Pie
Log in
Bag 0
  • Featured
      • Featured Items
        • Bicycle Pie (Our Line!)
        • New Arrivals
        • Best Sellers
        • Summer Favorites
        • Brand Spotlight: Angel Dear
        • Baby Essentials
        • Getaway Shop
        • Sale
        • View All
      Plains, Trains & Automobiles
      NEW ON OUR SHELVES
      COLOR OUTSIDE THE LINES
  • Clothes
      • Shop by Size
        • Newborn
        • Baby Girl (0-24 M)
        • Baby Boy (0-24 M)
        • Baby Neutral (0-24 M)
        • Girl (2+)
        • Boy (2+)
        • Accessories
        • View All
      • Shop by Style
        • Footies & Rompers
        • Bodysuits
        • Tops & Tees
        • Bottoms & Overalls
        • One Pieces
        • Dresses
        • Outfits & Sets
        • PJs & Loungewear
        • Sleeper Gowns
        • Hats & Headbands
        • View All
      Spring outfits, simplified.
      Easy sets for busy little days.
  • Toys
      • Shop by Age
        • Baby
        • 0-2 Years
        • 3-5 Years
        • 6-8 Years
        • 8+ Years
      • Shop by Category
        • First Toys
        • Soft Toys & Loveys
        • Arts & Crafts
        • Building Sets
        • Dolls
        • Plush
        • Creative
        • STEM & Learning Tools
        • Games & Puzzles
        • Play Figures
        • Vehicles & Work Trucks
        • Wooden Toys
        • View All
      New (LEGO) bricks on the block
      Crafting - naturally - with elseware unplugg
  • Books
      • Shop By Age
        • Baby
        • 0-2 Years
        • 3-5 Years
        • 6-8 Years
        • 8+ Years
      • Shop By Theme
        • Board Books
        • Picture Books
        • Giftable
        • Bedtime
        • Animals & Nature
        • People & Places
        • Vehicles
        • Graphic Novels
        • Chapter Books
        • View All
      The Sweetest Stories to Gift & Keep
      Read Now. Remember Forever.
  • Gifts
      • Shop By Age
        • Baby
        • 0-2 Years
        • 3-5 Years
        • 6-8 Years
        • 8+ Years
      • Gift Ideas
        • Baby Shower
        • Birthdays
        • The Party Shop
        • Sibling Gifts
        • Cities & Towns
        • Swaddles & Blankets
        • Sleepsacks & Nursery
        • Mealtime
        • Cards & Paper Goods
        • Gift Cards
        • View All
      Spread the sibling love hats & tees
      Shop cozy swaddles & blankets
  • Shop by Age
      • Baby
      • 0-2 Years
      • 3-5 Years
      • 6-7 Years
      • 8+ Years
  • Blog
    • How to Choose High-Quality Toys: A Mom of Four Shares What’s Worth Buying
      #MomLife
      How to Choose High-Quality Toys: A Mom of Four Shares What’s Worth Buying
      Read Blog
      5 April Fools’ Day Pranks That Are Silly (Not Scary)
      DIY Activities
      5 April Fools’ Day Pranks That Are Silly (Not Scary)
      Read Blog
      Confessions of a Reluctant Dumpling Dealer
      Product Roundups
      Confessions of a Reluctant Dumpling Dealer
      Read Blog
  • Featured
    • Featured
    • Featured Items
      • Bicycle Pie (Our Line!)
      • New Arrivals
      • Best Sellers
      • Summer Favorites
      • Brand Spotlight: Angel Dear
      • Baby Essentials
      • Getaway Shop
      • Sale
      • View All
  • Clothes
    • Clothes
    • Shop by Size
      • Newborn
      • Baby Girl (0-24 M)
      • Baby Boy (0-24 M)
      • Baby Neutral (0-24 M)
      • Girl (2+)
      • Boy (2+)
      • Accessories
      • View All
    • Shop by Style
      • Footies & Rompers
      • Bodysuits
      • Tops & Tees
      • Bottoms & Overalls
      • One Pieces
      • Dresses
      • Outfits & Sets
      • PJs & Loungewear
      • Sleeper Gowns
      • Hats & Headbands
      • View All
  • Toys
    • Toys
    • Shop by Age
      • Baby
      • 0-2 Years
      • 3-5 Years
      • 6-8 Years
      • 8+ Years
    • Shop by Category
      • First Toys
      • Soft Toys & Loveys
      • Arts & Crafts
      • Building Sets
      • Dolls
      • Plush
      • Creative
      • STEM & Learning Tools
      • Games & Puzzles
      • Play Figures
      • Vehicles & Work Trucks
      • Wooden Toys
      • View All
  • Books
    • Books
    • Shop By Age
      • Baby
      • 0-2 Years
      • 3-5 Years
      • 6-8 Years
      • 8+ Years
    • Shop By Theme
      • Board Books
      • Picture Books
      • Giftable
      • Bedtime
      • Animals & Nature
      • People & Places
      • Vehicles
      • Graphic Novels
      • Chapter Books
      • View All
  • Gifts
    • Gifts
    • Shop By Age
      • Baby
      • 0-2 Years
      • 3-5 Years
      • 6-8 Years
      • 8+ Years
    • Gift Ideas
      • Baby Shower
      • Birthdays
      • The Party Shop
      • Sibling Gifts
      • Cities & Towns
      • Swaddles & Blankets
      • Sleepsacks & Nursery
      • Mealtime
      • Cards & Paper Goods
      • Gift Cards
      • View All
  • Shop by Age
    • Shop by Age
    • Baby
    • 0-2 Years
    • 3-5 Years
    • 6-7 Years
    • 8+ Years
  • Blog
    • Blog
    • #MomLife
    • DIY Activities
    • Product Roundups
  • Login
  • About Bicycle Pie
  • Contact Us
  1. Home
  2. First Toys

First Toys

Refine By

Refine By

view all

Age

  • Baby
  • 0-2 Years
  • 3-5 Years
  • 6-8 Years

Brand

  • Cheengoo
  • Tender Leaf Toys
  • Mary Meyer
  • Meri Meri
  • The Blueberry Hill
  • Gummy Chic
  • Ali+Oli
  • HABA
  • Estella
  • Itzy Ritzy
  • Fat Brain Toys
  • Hape
  • Oli & Carol

Collection

  • First Toys
clear
Wooden Rattle with Silicone Beads (Cloud)
Ali+Oli
Wooden Rattle with Silicone Beads (Cloud)
$19.99
Cloud Rattle
Cheengoo
Cloud Rattle
$12.50
Yellow Donut Rattle
Cheengoo
Yellow Donut Rattle
$13.00
Crocheted Avocado Teething Rattle
Cheengoo
Crocheted Avocado Teething Rattle
$19.00
Robot Rattle
Cheengoo
Robot Rattle
$14.00
Cassette Tape Teether with Colored Clip, Black
Gummy Chic
Cassette Tape Teether with Colored Clip, Black
$28.00
Vinyl Record Teether with Clip
Gummy Chic
Vinyl Record Teether with Clip
$25.00
Cassette Tape Teether with Clip, Pink
Gummy Chic
Cassette Tape Teether with Clip, Pink
$28.00
Designed in Germany by Gummy Chic, this teether offers multiple textures, both front and back, to provide the best sensory surfaces for much-needed teething relief. Made of 100% food-grade silicone and free from harmful chemicals, this soft baby teether is durable enough for even the most avid chewers. The teething beads are also safe for baby.
Gummy Chic
Cassette Tape Teether with Clip, Light Grey
$28.00
Retro Video Game Teether
Gummy Chic
Retro Video Game Teether
$14.99
Banana Baby Rattle
Meri Meri
Banana Baby Rattle
$22.00
Pink Ice Cream Baby Rattle
Meri Meri
Pink Ice Cream Baby Rattle
$20.00
Reindeer Rattle
Cheengoo
Reindeer Rattle
$13.00
Knitted Nursery Lion Rattle
Mary Meyer
Knitted Nursery Lion Rattle
$9.99
Organic Basketball Rattle
Estella
Organic Basketball Rattle
$22.00
Organic Pretzel Rattle
Estella
Organic Pretzel Rattle
$25.00
Organic Hot Dog Rattle
Estella
Organic Hot Dog Rattle
$25.00
Soft Silicone Mini-Animal 4-Piece Puzzle
Ali+Oli
Soft Silicone Mini-Animal 4-Piece Puzzle
$22.99
Wooden Rattle with Silicone Beads (Pink)
Ali+Oli
Wooden Rattle with Silicone Beads (Pink)
$19.99
White Donut Rattle
Cheengoo
White Donut Rattle
$13.00
Rotary Dial Phone Teether with Clip, Camel
Gummy Chic
Rotary Dial Phone Teether with Clip, Camel
$28.00
Rotary Dial Phone Teether, Pink
Gummy Chic
Rotary Dial Phone Teether, Pink
$14.99
Rotary Dial Phone Teether, Desert Sage
Gummy Chic
Rotary Dial Phone Teether, Desert Sage
$14.99
Pink Rainbow Rattle Teether
Cheengoo
Pink Rainbow Rattle Teether
$18.00
Previous 1 2 3 4 Next

From first rattles to first stackers, these are the toys that grow alongside baby's earliest discoveries.

Shop
  • Bicycle Pie
  • New Arrivals
  • Best Sellers
  • Sale
  • Clothes
  • Toys
  • Books
  • Gifts
Shop By Age
  • Baby
  • 0-2 Years
  • 3-5 Years
  • 6-7 Years
  • 8+ Years
Explore
  • #MomLife
  • DIY Activities
  • Product Roundups
  • About Bicycle Pie
Customer Help
  • FAQ
  • Contact Us
  • Returns & Exchanges
  • Shipping Policy

Keep In Touch

Read. Shop. Pie. Gift ideas, product reviews, engaging content, right to your inbox.

©2026 Bicycle PiePrivacyTerms + ConditionsSite By Aeolidia